Pro-life group ‘goes far too far,’ says bishop

Montreal -- Some Quebec bishops have expressed alarm that the main Quebec organizer for the May 9 National March for Life in Ottawa signed a letter accusing Pope Francis of heresy.

Bishop Noël Simard, president of the Assembly of Catholic Bishops of Quebec, did not mince his words May 6 about the anti-Pope letter signed by the president of Campagne Quebec-Vie, the province’s main Catholic pro-life group.

“I used to send a cheque to Campagne Quebec-Vie every year. But now it’s over,” said Simard, a bioethics specialist, who added he was only speaking on his behalf and not for his fellow bishops.

“Attacking Pope Francis this way is going far too far,” he said about the letter signed by 19 Catholics from different countries. Only one Canadian initially signed this letter: Georges Buscemi, who has been in charge of Campagne Quebec-Vie since 2009.

Buscemi and the other signatories, including theologians and religious, asked bishops and cardinals to accuse Pope Francis of the “canonical offence of heresy” and to take the necessary measures against him.

On May 3, the Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops sent a press release promoting the National March for Life. However, in doing so, it posted links directly to Campagne Quebec-Vie’s website, where Buscemi invited citizens to “defend without shame the right to life for all human beings.”

On May 9, the bishops posted a new statement that began: “The Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops (CCCB), in profound unison with Pope Francis, affirms that all human life should be respected and protected from the moment of conception until natural death.”

“This whole situation is very delicate,” said Simard, who heads the Diocese of Valleyfield.

Simard remains convinced that the March for Life remains relevant. However, he said, “the problem is when one of the organizers takes unacceptable positions, in this case against the Pope. It certainly makes allegiance more difficult.”

“It must be addressed,” he added, but “we mustn’t reject everything because of a stance we don’t agree with.”

On May 5, Archbishop Christian Lépine of Montreal said the March’s goal is unchanged: “The idea of respect for life, or promoting life: atheists do it, Jews do it, Christians do it. ... So I keep the focus on it,” he said, suggesting people with different ideas can still commit to the cause. “The call to respect life is beyond that.”

Jasmin Lemieux-Lefebvre, director of communications for the Archdiocese of Quebec, said May 6 that Cardinal Gerald Lacroix did not want to comment on the situation. The archdiocese’s website invited Catholics to participate in the National March for Life.

However, the archdiocesan spokesman said: “We would like to share our deep disappointment that the president of the main Quebec organization supporting the March may have even thought of supporting a letter accusing Pope Francis of heresy.”

Lemieux-Lefebvre said he personally contacted Buscemi “to let him know that by signing this letter, he was endangering the credibility” of the March.

“We always believe in the importance of publicly bearing witness to the dignity of human life, from conception to natural death, but let us be clear: We don’t want to be associated with anyone who unfairly accuses the Holy Father,” he said. “Our communion with Pope Francis is complete.”

Buscemi said he is well aware that signing a letter accusing Pope Francis of heresy could well offend Catholics and bishops.

“But the resolution of the crisis in the Church is more important,” he said. “The Church is responsible for teaching true faith and true morality to every human person. When its leader fails, the whole planet suffers, not only Catholics or pro-life.”